
The Pfister Hotel
Best for travelers who want a historic, full-service downtown hotel with multiple dining options, an on-site spa, and a 23rd-floor indoor pool with lake views.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Pfister Hotel is a landmark, full-service historic hotel in downtown Milwaukee with classic rooms, multiple restaurants, a 23rd-floor indoor pool, and an on-site spa. Aloft by Marriott Milwaukee Downtown is a 3-star, trendy select-service hotel with modern design and a casual social vibe—compare these if you want either a refined, full-service stay (Pfister) or a contemporary, value-oriented downtown option (Aloft).
Updated · about 1.2 km apart

Best for travelers who want a historic, full-service downtown hotel with multiple dining options, an on-site spa, and a 23rd-floor indoor pool with lake views.

Best for travelers who want a modern, budget-conscious downtown stay with a lively, social public space and convenient proximity to Fiserv Forum.
When The Pfister wins: pick The Pfister if you want classic Victorian-era character, a full-service experience (spa, multiple restaurants and lounges, larger event spaces), a 23rd-floor pool with Lake Michigan views, or if you value more room types and suites.
When Aloft wins: pick Aloft if you prefer a contemporary, select-service Marriott-brand property with a casual, social lobby scene, straightforward modern rooms, and a lower-star, value-oriented price point; it’s also very close to Fiserv Forum and downtown venues.
Bottom line: The Pfister is a downtown, full-service luxury option for guests wanting on-site dining, spa services, and a historic atmosphere; Aloft is a three-star, design-forward alternative for travelers who prioritize modern style, convenience, and a social vibe over full-service amenities.
| Category | The Pfister Hotel | Aloft |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, refined, full-service luxury | Trendy, casual, select-service |
| Location (downtown) | 424 E Wisconsin Ave — central downtown near RiverWalk, theaters, museums | 1230 N. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Drive — in Westown near Fiserv Forum |
| Size | 307 guestrooms, 82 suites | 160 guestrooms |
| Star rating / guest rating | Luxury / not given in dossier for star; high guest satisfaction noted | 3 stars · guest rating 8.6 |
| Pools | Indoor pool on the 23rd floor with Lake Michigan views (open daily 6:00 AM–10:00 PM) | Indoor pool (hours: listed as pool access 7:00 AM–10:00 PM in supplier listing) |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple outlets: Mason Street Grill, Café at the Pfister, Lobby Lounge, Blu (23rd-floor cocktail bar) | Restaurant serving guests plus snack bar/deli and a bar/lounge |
| Spa & wellness | WELL Spa + Salon on-site (11 treatment rooms; appointment only) | Not published |
| Known for | Historic 1893 building, Victorian details, full-service hotel and meeting space | Marriott-backed Aloft brand, modern design, social public spaces |
| Event & meeting space | More than 25,000 sq ft including multiple ballrooms and many meeting rooms | Conference space ~2,196 sq ft and meeting rooms (select-service meeting capacity) |
| Nearby highlights | Milwaukee Art Museum, RiverWalk, Historic Third Ward, theaters within walking distance | Within a 5-minute walk of Fiserv Forum and Milwaukee School of Engineering |
The Pfister sits in the heart of downtown Milwaukee on E Wisconsin Ave near the RiverWalk and cultural venues.
Choose The Pfister if you want classic downtown proximity to museums, theaters, and the RiverWalk.
Aloft by Marriott Milwaukee Downtown is in Westown and places you very near Fiserv Forum and downtown event venues.
Choose Aloft if you need ultra-close access to Fiserv Forum and nearby event venues.
The Pfister offers a wide range of room types, including many suites and lake-view rooms.
The Pfister is better if you want suites or a broader selection of room types and more in-room space.
Aloft offers contemporary, compact rooms in typical Aloft/Marriott style.
Aloft is a straightforward, modern option for travelers wanting a compact, accessible room with practical amenities.
The Pfister has several on-site dining and drinking venues covering breakfast to late-night cocktails.
The Pfister suits guests who want diverse on-site dining and evening lounge options.
Aloft’s food & drink setup focuses on casual, quick dining and a social bar/lounge.
Aloft is better if you want casual dining, quick bites, and a lively lobby bar rather than multiple formal restaurants.
The Pfister’s signature pool sits on the 23rd floor with views toward Lake Michigan.
The Pfister’s rooftop-level pool is a differentiator for guests who value a scenic swim in downtown Milwaukee.
Aloft provides an indoor pool as part of its on-site recreational options.
Aloft has a practical indoor pool, but it’s presented as one amenity among others rather than a signature selling point.
The Pfister emphasizes on-site spa services and refined evening lounges.
Choose The Pfister for a full-service spa experience and a quieter, refined evening scene.
Aloft emphasizes a casual social lobby and 24-hour fitness.
Aloft works well if you want a lively, social hotel environment and round-the-clock fitness rather than a full-service spa.

The Pfister — WELL Spa + Salon with appointment-only treatments, steam room, Turkish bath, and couples rooms.

Aloft — steps from Fiserv Forum and a short walk to downtown event venues.

The Pfister — Victorian-era building with extensive ballroom and meeting space for weddings and conferences.

Aloft — contemporary design, social lobby/bar, and practical downtown rooms at a 3-star price point.
The Pfister — it has an on-site WELL Spa + Salon with a wide range of appointment-only services.
Aloft — it’s within a 5-minute walk of Fiserv Forum and geared toward event attendees.
Yes. The Pfister’s 23rd-floor pool is open daily 6:00 AM–10:00 PM; Aloft lists pool access (supplier hours show roughly 7:00 AM–10:00 PM).
The Pfister is family-friendly with cribs, a family-friendly pool option, and suites; Aloft is also family-friendly but is a select-service hotel geared toward a younger, social crowd.
Explore how The Pfister Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·